Universalists Through Church History

Author: Mercy Aiken & Gary Amirault  

Published: Dec 6, 1998

Reading Time: 6 Minutes

Like a golden thread woven through the Bible, so runs the doctrine of the restoration of all things. While not immediately apparent, once visible, it stands out as a central doctrine of both Old and New Testaments.

In the same way, universalist thought also runs like a stream throughout church history; sometimes flowing strong and clear, other times running mostly underground. The wellspring of this doctrine flows from the apostolic church of the New Testament, and is clearly expressed in Paul’s writings. Starting in the first century of Christianity, the doctrine was developed most acutely amongst the native Greek speakers–those who were closest to the heart and times in which the New Testament was written. These early leaders cast a long shadow of influence upon the church, as others carried their torch—but perhaps their greatest influence has been reserved for our day and age.

Just as our forefathers suffered and died martyr’s deaths for truths that we take for granted today and that are universally accepted across Christendom, so today cries of heresy continue to arise against truths that we believe future generations of the church will hold to be evident. But so is the pattern of the ongoing Christian reformation!

A criticism that has sometimes been levied against Christian universalism is that it has never been accepted as a biblical doctrine by the majority of the church. While we think that the true measure of a doctrine should be Scripture itself, and not necessarily the majority, we nevertheless recognize the importance of apostles, prophets, pastors, teachers and evangelists who have been given to the church at large by the Lord Himself. There is much to learn from studying the lives and doctrines of those who have gone before us—and what may be surprising to some, is that there actually have been many respected leaders throughout the history of the church who have grappled with or embraced this idea. Indeed, every true Christian has struggled at some point with the idea of eternal torment for non-believers. However, because Scripture apparently teaches it emphatically and because the majority leadership have declared that ultimate reconciliation is heresy (and some go so far as to say that it is heresy even to study the idea), a typical believer is left with no option but to continue believing in eternal torment.

We hope that this page will help to change that. While we have much information on Tentmaker, we hope this page will also be helpful for the person who needs to see others who have also studied or embraced this doctrine. We use the term “Christian Universalism in the article, but this glorious teaching is as old as the first book of the Bible and has been preached under many different names, just to mention a few: Universalism, Larger Hope, Greater Faith, No-Hellers, Ultimate Reconciliation, Universal Salvation, Universal Restitution, Universal Restoration, Doctrine of Inclusion, Glorious Gospel and more. I personally (Gary Amirault, founder of Tentmaker) have been calling it “The Victorious Gospel of Jesus Christ.” I like the ring of that phrase. It is victory centered, Gospel centered and Christ centered. It is positive and bold. I am hoping more people in this message begin to use this term to describe Christ’s victorious plan to save all mankind.

Please note that while not every person listed on this page would necessarily call themselves a universalist, all of these are people who grappled with the issue of salvation, redemption, Hell, and the fate of the unsaved. While some leaders merely expressed hope for the possibility of an ultimate reconciliation, or were sympathetic to the idea, others confidently asserted its truth, proving it from Scripture.

We include them on this page, in the hopes that some who have been afraid to study the subject of universal redemption for fear of heresy, will see that many of the great minds of the church have at least been open to the idea–while others have been strongly supportive of the doctrine.

May the boldness of thought represented on these pages encourage others to also think boldly, largely—and scripturally—of our God. Surely there is a great reformation on the horizon of the Christian church, and the doctrine of the restitution of all things is certainly a part of it!

May God bless and open the eyes and ears of all who read these pages.

Please noteThis page is a work in progress and will be expanded considerably. The biographies are not extensive—rather they are mere brief introductions to these lives. There are many more names that need to be added, including many contemporary Christians.

These pages are being edited and compiled by Mercy Aiken, Gary Amirault and others.

For a longer list of writers, pastors, Bible scholars, humanitarians, Statesmen who embraced the message of universalism, also known as Universal Salvation, Ultimate Reconciliation, Universal Restoration, The Larger Hope, The Greater Faith, apokatastasis, the Restoration of All Things, Doctrine of Inclusion, etc. 

[Editor’s note (2026), where there was no Tentmaker biography available, we have added the link to the persons Wikipedia page. Aiming to be as accurate as possible to who we think was being referenced.]

Universalists Through Church History
The DidascaliaPantaenus
Clement of AlexandriaOrigen of Alexandria
Athanasius of AlexandriaDidymus, the Blind
Ambrose of MilanJohn Chrysostom
Gregory of NyssaMacrina the Younger
Basil the GreatGregory of Nazianzus
Theodore of MopsuestiaEusebius of Caesarea
Diodore of TarsusSt. Jerome
Maximus of TurinClement of Ireland
John Scotus EriugenaJohannes Tauler
Julian of NorwichJohn Donne
Jakob BöhmeGerrard Winstanley
Hans DenckJane Leade
The AnabaptistsThe Albigenses
The LollardsPeter Böhler (and the Moravians)
William LawSir Isaac Newton
Johann Kaspar LavaterVictor Hugo
John DonneCharles Kingsley
Isaac WattsMarie Huber
Anne BrontëJ. F. Oberlin
Immanuel KantJames Relly
Nathaniel Scarlett (1753–1802)Lord and Lady Byron
Robert and Elizabeth BrowningWilliam King, Archbishop of Dublin
Lewis CarrollSamuel Johnson
Thomas HobbesElhanan Winchester
George WashingtonBenjamin Franklin
Benjamin RushJohn Murray
Thomas J. PotterHosea Ballou
Hannah Whitall SmithBishop B. F. Westcott
Dr. George De BennevilleFlorence Nightingale
Clara BartonJohn Wesley (J. W.) Hanson
Thomas AllinJames Relly
Abraham LincolnJudith Sargent Murray
Rev. Charles H. PridgeonSadhu Sundar Singh
Thomas WhittemoreCanon Frederic William (F.W.) Farrar
Hans Christian AndersenHarriet Beecher Stowe
Henry Ward BeecherAndrew Jukes
Friedrich SchleiermacherCanon Basil Wilberforce
John A. T. RobinsonAdolph Ernest (A.E.) Knoch
A. P. AdamsGeorge MacDonald
Paul TillichJacques Ellul
Karl BarthHannah Hurnard
Hans Urs von BalthasarRay Prinzing
J. Preston EbyWilliam Barclay
Ernest L. MartinJürgen Moltmann
Bishop Desmond Mpilo Tutu
Non-Universalists on This Subject
Finis DakeRobert G. Ingersoll
G. K. ChestertonCatherine Marshall
John G. LakeAndrew Murray
C. S. Lewis

For another and more extensive list of names without biography links see: https://tentmaker.org/tracts/believers-and-supporters-of-christian-universalism/

On This Page

On This Page